How is the condition made in the state of ihram?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Sharafi: May Allah reward you. Is it better to say, "My place of exit is where I am detained," or "It is permissible for me to exit"? And what is the criterion for the illness or its like that detains a person?
The Shaykh : The first point: Is it better to say, "If I am detained by a detainer, my place of exit is where I am detained," or to say, "It is permissible for me to exit"?
The difference between them is clear. If he says, "It is permissible for me to exit," he has the choice; if he wishes, he exits, and if he wishes, he completes the rites. Or, it is better to say:, as the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) guided Zubaydah to do, so that a person does not burden himself. For he might say, "I am able to perform the rites despite this detainer, even if it involves hardship." So the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) guided that the exit should be during the time of detention, so that a person does not burden himself.
There is no doubt that the phrase "It is permissible for me to exit" is broader, broader than saying:, because it gives the person the choice.
The questioner : Salim: May Allah forgive you. Regarding the lives of women, with the fatigue, and the travel, and the many changes in times, menstruation may come to them before its due date. Could this be what happened to Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her)?
The Shaykh : Yes, it is possible. It is possible that Aisha’s menstruation came early.
The questioner : Salim: But is it taken from this, O Shaykh, that a woman should make the condition because...?
The Shaykh : If she fears that menstruation will come to her, she makes the condition. For example, if her usual time is near and she fears it will come early due to, as I said, fatigue, there is no harm.
The Shaykh : The first point: Is it better to say, "If I am detained by a detainer, my place of exit is where I am detained," or to say, "It is permissible for me to exit"?
The difference between them is clear. If he says, "It is permissible for me to exit," he has the choice; if he wishes, he exits, and if he wishes, he completes the rites. Or, it is better to say:
If one who holds me back, then my place of sacrifice is where I am held.
إن حبسني حابس فمحلي حيث حبستنيThere is no doubt that the phrase "It is permissible for me to exit" is broader, broader than saying:
My place of exit is where I am detained
فمحلي حيث حبستنيThe questioner : Salim: May Allah forgive you. Regarding the lives of women, with the fatigue, and the travel, and the many changes in times, menstruation may come to them before its due date. Could this be what happened to Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her)?
The Shaykh : Yes, it is possible. It is possible that Aisha’s menstruation came early.
The questioner : Salim: But is it taken from this, O Shaykh, that a woman should make the condition because...?
The Shaykh : If she fears that menstruation will come to her, she makes the condition. For example, if her usual time is near and she fears it will come early due to, as I said, fatigue, there is no harm.