What is your opinion, O Shaykh, regarding what some scholars said about al-Khatib’s statement: “And as for ‘whoever obeys,’ he was only criticized for it because he said, ‘Whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger has succeeded, and whoever…”
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Shaykh, may Allah reward you. What some scholars mentioned regarding this phrase, “Whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger has succeeded and guided”, where they said that “whoever obeys Allah” was criticized because he said: “Whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger has succeeded, and whoever disobeys them” “then he paused and then said” “has gone astray” “so it is as if” “disobeys them” “became conjoined to?”
And Allah, this is far-fetched. This requires proof that he remained silent. That is one point. Then, a person does not remain silent while the speaker is speaking. He said, " And whoever disobeys them " then " has certainly gone astray." So it is known that this is dependent on what came before it.
And Allah, this is far-fetched. This requires proof that he remained silent. That is one point. Then, a person does not remain silent while the speaker is speaking. He said, " And whoever disobeys them " then " has certainly gone astray." So it is known that this is dependent on what came before it.