Does the action of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) abrogate his saying?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Does the action of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) abrogate his saying?
Answer:
As long as reconciliation is possible, abrogation is not resorted to except under two conditions:
The impossibility of reconciliation; it must be that reconciliation is not possible.
And the chronology must be known.
This is one of the causes of abrogation: when the chronology is known and reconciliation is not possible.
As for when reconciliation is possible or the chronology is not known, reconciliation is necessary, and abrogation is not possible.
Q: Who said that the action does not abrogate the saying, because the action...?
The Shaykh: Because the action is an explanation; it does not abrogate. The action explains.
Q: Perhaps it requires specificity?
The Shaykh: The action explains, yes.
Does the action of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) abrogate his saying?
Answer:
As long as reconciliation is possible, abrogation is not resorted to except under two conditions:
The impossibility of reconciliation; it must be that reconciliation is not possible.
And the chronology must be known.
This is one of the causes of abrogation: when the chronology is known and reconciliation is not possible.
As for when reconciliation is possible or the chronology is not known, reconciliation is necessary, and abrogation is not possible.
Q: Who said that the action does not abrogate the saying, because the action...?
The Shaykh: Because the action is an explanation; it does not abrogate. The action explains.
Q: Perhaps it requires specificity?
The Shaykh: The action explains, yes.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
