What is the authenticity of “As for silver, play with it as you wish”?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The hadith?
Answer:
There is doubt regarding its authenticity, and it appears to be an anomalous narration that contradicts the authentic hadiths, because they contain the prohibition of wearing gold... It was cited as evidence by those who prohibited the ring, and it appears from the hadiths that this is an anomalous narration. One of the proofs of its anomaly and lack of authenticity is the statement:. It is strange to think that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) would say this.
The hadith
As for silver, play with it as you wish
الفضة فالعبوا بها كيف شئتمAnswer:
There is doubt regarding its authenticity, and it appears to be an anomalous narration that contradicts the authentic hadiths, because they contain the prohibition of wearing gold... It was cited as evidence by those who prohibited the ring, and it appears from the hadiths that this is an anomalous narration. One of the proofs of its anomaly and lack of authenticity is the statement:
As for silver, play with it as play
الفضة فالعبوا بها لعبًا
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.