Does Ibn Malik’s statement, “Your father’s brother came in a state of strength,” imply that these nouns are indeclinable?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : All of them, all of them are indeclinable, even “brother” is indeclinable and “father” is indeclinable. The one that is required to be a derived noun is not the one in the state, but the state itself.
Then he said: “with the alif”. Do you have the grammatical analysis of the verse? What does it say?
The questioner : The state is in the accusative case with the alif...
The Shaykh : Otherwise, where does the state come from? Ah.
The questioner : Al-Khudri.
The Shaykh : And what does he say?
Then he said: “with the alif”. Do you have the grammatical analysis of the verse? What does it say?
The questioner : The state is in the accusative case with the alif...
The Shaykh : Otherwise, where does the state come from? Ah.
The questioner : Al-Khudri.
The Shaykh : And what does he say?