Is it prescribed to say the tahlil and takbir at the Black Stone?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
His statement: "So face it and say the tahlil and takbir"?
Answer:
As for his statement to 'Umar: it is a weak hadith, with an unknown shaykh in its chain, but its meaning is correct. Its meaning is that the Sunnah is not to push or harm people. If he finds a space, he touches it; if he does not find a space, he points to it. He does not push or harm people, especially since some people may be strong and cause harm. So the Sunnah is to point and walk away, not harming anyone or pushing.
And this hadith supports that, even though it is weak, but it supports the meaning. And the Sunnah is that the Prophet used to say: Allahu Akbar.
Q: Addition: "And say the tahlil and takbir"?
A: This is a weak hadith. What is known from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) is that he used to say the takbir.
His statement: "So face it and say the tahlil and takbir"?
Answer:
As for his statement to 'Umar:
Indeed, you are a strong man, so do not push at the Stone
إنَّك رجلٌ قوي فلا تُزاحم عند الحجرAnd this hadith supports that, even though it is weak, but it supports the meaning. And the Sunnah is that the Prophet used to say: Allahu Akbar.
Q: Addition: "And say the tahlil and takbir"?
A: This is a weak hadith. What is known from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) is that he used to say the takbir.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
