Combining Prayers Due to Rain: Is the First Voluntary Prayer Made Up?

The questioner : Combining Prayers Due to Rain: Is the First Voluntary Prayer Made Up?

The Shaykh : Between the two groups, there is no voluntary prayer, and it is not made up.

The questioner : A questioner says: What is the evidence?

The Shaykh : The evidence is the absence of any evidence.

The questioner : Abu Malik combined the 'Asr and Zuhr prayers... because it was the day I arrived from 'Umrah, yes. So Abu Yahya and Asfar came and said to him, "What about the prayer?" He said, "We have prayed." They asked, "How can there be no prayer?" I remained silent.

The Shaykh : How do you mean there is no prayer?

The questioner : I mean there is no voluntary prayer, the voluntary prayer after the obligatory one. So Abu Malik said, "There is no voluntary prayer. We have prayed, my brother. How did the prayer go?" I remained silent. He looked at me and said, "Abu 'Abdullah, did you hear anything from the Shaykh? Did you hear anything from the Shaykh?" I said, "By Allah, the Shaykh says there is no prayer, there is no prayer." He asked, "Why?" I told him, "There is no evidence that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), when he combined prayers, prayed the voluntary prayer." He said, "Okay, there is no evidence for the opposite." I said to him, "May Allah guide you, O Abu Muhammad..." He said to me, "I understood you. May Allah reward you with good."

Another questioner : Our Shaykh...

The Shaykh: No.