A man went to propose to a girl, but she refused, so he said to her, “You are to me like my sister.” Then he proposed to her again and she agreed. Does zihar occur?

Similar fatwas

• If a man says to his wife, "You are like my sister," is this zihar?Al-Albani
• Is a husband saying to his wife, "You are like my sister," considered zihar?Ibn Uthaymeen
• If a man intends to propose to a woman, but circumstances prevent him, and another man…Ibn Uthaymeen
• A man who was traveling and his family sent him word that they had proposed a girl he knew…Ibn Uthaymeen
• Ruling on considering zihar to be a divorceIbn Baz
• What is the ruling on a man who says to his wife: “You are like my mother,” or “You are…Al-Fawzan
• Is a sister zihar?Al-Albani
• The Ruling on Zihar and Its FormsIbn Uthaymeen
• If a man says to his wife, "You are forbidden to me," is this zihar or an oath?Ibn Uthaymeen
• If a wife says to her husband, "You are forbidden to me," is this considered zihar?Ibn Uthaymeen