A husband swore to his wife that if she bought him a cap, he would cut it into pieces, but she bought it while his financial situation was weak, so if he wants to expiate his oath by feeding poor people, it would cause him great hardship, and he cannot fast, and cutting it would be a waste of money, so what is your opinion?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : He says: A question in haste to solve a problem between a husband and wife, a strange and unusual question. A husband swore to his wife that if she bought him a cap, he would cut it into pieces. She bought it, and his financial situation is weak. If he wants to expiate his oath by feeding poor people, it would cause him severe hardship, and he cannot fast, and cutting it would be a waste of money.
The Shaykh : ... As long as he tightens it, we will tighten it on him.
Al-'Aid 'Abassi: Yes, if it is valid, explain its objectives. And does the drinker of intoxicants who has not repented enter Paradise? And since intoxicants have been forbidden in this world, what is the wisdom of their existence in the Hereafter? And does a person enter Paradise and be deprived of some of its foods and drinks? We ask for clarification of this with an explanation of the evidence.
The Shaykh : Is this one question or five questions?
Al-'Aid 'Abassi: What Allah willed, this is a collection.
The Shaykh : Explain to me... how?
The audience laughed
ضحك الحضورThe Shaykh : ... As long as he tightens it, we will tighten it on him.
Al-'Aid 'Abassi: Yes, if it is valid, explain its objectives. And does the drinker of intoxicants who has not repented enter Paradise? And since intoxicants have been forbidden in this world, what is the wisdom of their existence in the Hereafter? And does a person enter Paradise and be deprived of some of its foods and drinks? We ask for clarification of this with an explanation of the evidence.
The Shaykh : Is this one question or five questions?
Al-'Aid 'Abassi: What Allah willed, this is a collection.
The Shaykh : Explain to me... how?