What is the proportion of qudsi hadiths relative to prophetic hadiths?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : To complete the topic, regarding qudsi hadiths, does this apply...?
The Shaykh : Yes, the same statement applies, but first: regarding prophetic hadiths, the proportion of qudsi hadiths is very, very small; it is very small. Second: the proportion of authentic ones among them is also small. That is to say, if we assume the qudsi hadiths, and I do not know their exact number, if we assume there are five hundred, the proportion of authentic ones might be two hundred or so. The rest are not authentic, and perhaps we will not find a mass-transmitted report among these two hundred.
The questioner : Is marriage a pre-ordained portion, meaning it is determined at the moment of birth?
The Shaykh : At the moment of what?
The questioner : The birth of the girl, it is written for her.
The Shaykh : At the moment he wants it, it is written for him.
The questioner : For him or for her, I mean the issue is a creedal problem, meaning it is written at the time of birth.
The Shaykh : And before birth, what is the problem? This is before birth,.
The Shaykh : Yes, the same statement applies, but first: regarding prophetic hadiths, the proportion of qudsi hadiths is very, very small; it is very small. Second: the proportion of authentic ones among them is also small. That is to say, if we assume the qudsi hadiths, and I do not know their exact number, if we assume there are five hundred, the proportion of authentic ones might be two hundred or so. The rest are not authentic, and perhaps we will not find a mass-transmitted report among these two hundred.
The questioner : Is marriage a pre-ordained portion, meaning it is determined at the moment of birth?
The Shaykh : At the moment of what?
The questioner : The birth of the girl, it is written for her.
The Shaykh : At the moment he wants it, it is written for him.
The questioner : For him or for her, I mean the issue is a creedal problem, meaning it is written at the time of birth.
The Shaykh : And before birth, what is the problem? This is before birth,
Everything is by divine decree...
كل شيء بقدر ...
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
