Is supplication for your deceased brother like supplication for him in his absence, such that the angels say to him: (And for you the same)?

Machine translationRead the Arabic original

The questioner : In this case, if a Muslim supplicates for his deceased brother, is the ruling the same as the ruling for one who supplicates for his living brother in his absence, meaning the angel says to him: And for you the same?

The Shaykh : Allah knows best.

The questioner : Allah knows best.

Source www.al-albany.com

The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.

Similar fatwas

Is supplication for the dead a form of supplication in their absence?Ibn Baz
Chapter on the virtue of supplicating for a brother in his absence: Allah the Exalted saidIbn Uthaymeen
Ruling on asking a brother to make du'a for his brotherIbn Baz
Does the deceased benefit from supplication? And does he know who supplicated for him?Ibn Baz
What is the expiation for backbiting, and is supplication for the person sufficient?Ibn Uthaymeen
What is the ruling on a Muslim asking his Muslim brother to pray for him in his absence…Ibn Uthaymeen
What is the ruling on a brother asking his brother to make du'a for him to Allah by…Ibn Uthaymeen
The ruling on one who claims that the Messenger of Allah knows the unseenAl-Fawzan
The ruling on invoking evil upon others in their absence or presenceIbn Baz
Ruling on Asking Others for SupplicationIbn Uthaymeen