The Meaning of the Poet's Statement: "And the one who denies the attributes reported the words of the affirmers, saying that Allah has a body, and he reported to us that the deniers said that Allah is not seen with the eye"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"And the one who denies the attributes reported the words of the affirmers, saying that Allah has a body"
This is a lie. "Juthman" means a body. He says, "You, the affirmers, say that Allah the Exalted has hearing, sight, hands, and a face, and so on. This necessitates that He is a body. Therefore, you are those who ascribe a body to Allah and those who ascribe a body to Him. From where does 'mujathimah' come? From 'juthman.' All right."
"And he reported to us that the deniers said that Allah is not seen by us with the eye"
The deniers of the attributes say that the people of the Sunnah say that Allah is not seen with the eye. Is this correct? It is a lie against them. They say that Allah is seen with the eye. Whoever denies the vision is in danger, and some of them may declare him a disbeliever. Some of them declared him a disbeliever.
"And the denier reported that they said it is permissible for His speech to be without intending meanings"
How? It means that it is permissible for Allah Mighty and Majestic to speak without intending the meaning. For this reason, they separated the words from the meaning. Some of them said that speech is only the meanings, and some of them said that speech is only the words. But speech, according to the people of the Sunnah, is both the words and the meaning together.
This is a lie. "Juthman" means a body. He says, "You, the affirmers, say that Allah the Exalted has hearing, sight, hands, and a face, and so on. This necessitates that He is a body. Therefore, you are those who ascribe a body to Allah and those who ascribe a body to Him. From where does 'mujathimah' come? From 'juthman.' All right."
"And he reported to us that the deniers said that Allah is not seen by us with the eye"
The deniers of the attributes say that the people of the Sunnah say that Allah is not seen with the eye. Is this correct? It is a lie against them. They say that Allah is seen with the eye. Whoever denies the vision is in danger, and some of them may declare him a disbeliever. Some of them declared him a disbeliever.
"And the denier reported that they said it is permissible for His speech to be without intending meanings"
How? It means that it is permissible for Allah Mighty and Majestic to speak without intending the meaning. For this reason, they separated the words from the meaning. Some of them said that speech is only the meanings, and some of them said that speech is only the words. But speech, according to the people of the Sunnah, is both the words and the meaning together.