A man who will perform Hajj at the expense of another person, has not yet performed the Hajj of Islam, and has a due debt: Is Hajj obligatory upon him?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : He says: A man is going to perform Hajj at the expense of another person for a charitable work, and he has not yet performed the Hajj of Islam, and he has a due debt. Is Hajj obligatory upon him?
Answer: If he has a due debt, it appears that Hajj is not obligatory upon him, because the scholars say: One does not become able to perform Hajj by the expenditure of another person for him. Did you understand?
Yes, indeed. However, if he performs Hajj, there is no harm, his Hajj is valid, and it suffices for the Hajj of Islam.
Answer: If he has a due debt, it appears that Hajj is not obligatory upon him, because the scholars say: One does not become able to perform Hajj by the expenditure of another person for him. Did you understand?
Yes, indeed. However, if he performs Hajj, there is no harm, his Hajj is valid, and it suffices for the Hajj of Islam.