Is it permissible for the companion of women to stone the pillars with them before the dawn prayer?

The questioner : It is known from the hadith of Asma' that it is permitted for the weak to stone the pillars even before the dawn prayer if they arrive at Mina. So, is it permissible for their companion, who is not weak but is accompanying them, to stone the pillars?

The Shaykh : There is no harm, there is no harm in his stoning the pillars, because the saying of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), as reported from him, that he said to Ibn Abbas regarding the young men: This hadith is disconnected (munqati') and cannot be used as evidence, even though some people have graded it as authentic, but their grading it as authentic is not correct; it is not correct.