What is the difference between the izar and the rida' regarding the permissibility of using buttons for the izar but not for the rida'?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Regarding what we mentioned, we said that if a button is added to the izar, that is permissible. Then we prohibited it in the case of the rida', even though the two forms are similar and...?
The Shaykh : No, absolutely not. Because the first is an izar, and when the izar is wrapped and tied, it resembles this, and that is permissible. That one, yes, must be loose from the shirt. If there is doubt about a button, it becomes like a shirt. With the button, it is tailored to the shape of the body; it becomes fitted to the shape of the body.
The Shaykh : No, absolutely not. Because the first is an izar, and when the izar is wrapped and tied, it resembles this, and that is permissible. That one, yes, must be loose from the shirt. If there is doubt about a button, it becomes like a shirt. With the button, it is tailored to the shape of the body; it becomes fitted to the shape of the body.