What is the meaning of the author's statement: "Then the reason for the fulfillment of the needs of some of these supplicants who make forbidden supplications
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh, may Allah reward you, the author's statement: "even though intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah"
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : The author's statement: "even though intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah" Was this absolute?
The Shaykh : Yes, the one in dire necessity may be at his idol and supplicate to Allah the Exalted, and Allah may answer his supplication.
The questioner : His statement that intentionally doing so at this idol is associating partners with Allah; supplicating at this is associating partners with Allah.
The Shaykh : The one in dire necessity, no matter what, Allah answers his supplication, and the oppressed, no matter what, Allah answers his supplication.
The questioner : I am not speaking about the answering of the supplication, O Shaykh, I am speaking about the intention of this act... intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah, even now those who intentionally supplicate at some graves, claiming that they are from the righteous
The Shaykh : No, no, did he say it is associating partners with Allah or that he is a polytheist?
The questioner : He said it is associating partners with Allah.
The Shaykh : Read the phrase, read it.
The questioner :"even though intentionally supplicating"
The Shaykh : Before, before "even though"
The questioner :"Then the reason for the fulfillment of the needs of some of these supplicants who make forbidden supplications is that one of them may be in a state of dire necessity such that if he were to supplicate to Allah with it as a polytheist at an idol, it would be answered for him, because his turning toward Allah was sincere, even though intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah".
The Shaykh : Even though?
The questioner :"intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah"
The Shaykh : Yes, the idol that he believes answers his supplication.
The Shaykh : What?
The questioner : The author's statement: "even though intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah" Was this absolute?
The Shaykh : Yes, the one in dire necessity may be at his idol and supplicate to Allah the Exalted, and Allah may answer his supplication.
The questioner : His statement that intentionally doing so at this idol is associating partners with Allah; supplicating at this is associating partners with Allah.
The Shaykh : The one in dire necessity, no matter what, Allah answers his supplication, and the oppressed, no matter what, Allah answers his supplication.
The questioner : I am not speaking about the answering of the supplication, O Shaykh, I am speaking about the intention of this act... intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah, even now those who intentionally supplicate at some graves, claiming that they are from the righteous
The Shaykh : No, no, did he say it is associating partners with Allah or that he is a polytheist?
The questioner : He said it is associating partners with Allah.
The Shaykh : Read the phrase, read it.
The questioner :"even though intentionally supplicating"
The Shaykh : Before, before "even though"
The questioner :"Then the reason for the fulfillment of the needs of some of these supplicants who make forbidden supplications is that one of them may be in a state of dire necessity such that if he were to supplicate to Allah with it as a polytheist at an idol, it would be answered for him, because his turning toward Allah was sincere, even though intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah".
The Shaykh : Even though?
The questioner :"intentionally supplicating at an idol is associating partners with Allah"
The Shaykh : Yes, the idol that he believes answers his supplication.