Is it derived from this hadith that if some of the righteous are found asking about their deeds in secret?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is it derived from this hadith ... from one of the righteous that you ask the one who knows about him regarding his deeds?
The Shaykh : The apparent view is that it does not indicate that, yes. Because the Messenger is the imam and the role model, whereas others are not our imam and role model like the role model of the Messenger. And although there is no doubt that the people of good are followed as examples, their words are not a proof and do not establish a religious obligation, yes.
The Shaykh : The apparent view is that it does not indicate that, yes. Because the Messenger is the imam and the role model, whereas others are not our imam and role model like the role model of the Messenger. And although there is no doubt that the people of good are followed as examples, their words are not a proof and do not establish a religious obligation, yes.