One who has a make-up Hajj as a mutamatti' and then performed it as an ifrad: is there anything required of him?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : We said in our discussion before the first exit from the state of ihram that five rulings are obligatory upon him: making up the Hajj?
The Shaykh : They follow from it.
The questioner : Five rulings follow from it: making up the Hajj with any type of Hajj, or with the type of Hajj that was invalidated?
The Shaykh : Not with the type of Hajj that was invalidated.
The questioner : Now, if he makes it up, for example, as a mutamatti', or if he makes it up as an ifrad, is the blood of the tamattu' obligatory upon him? No, it is not obligatory upon him because he did not perform tamattu'. However, we say: it is obligatory for you to make it up as a mutamatti', because Hajj al-tamattu' is better than Hajj al-ifrad.
The questioner : If he is unable to perform tamattu'?
The Shaykh : If he is unable to perform tamattu', there is nothing upon him; he becomes an ifrad and there is nothing upon him.
The Shaykh : They follow from it.
The questioner : Five rulings follow from it: making up the Hajj with any type of Hajj, or with the type of Hajj that was invalidated?
The Shaykh : Not with the type of Hajj that was invalidated.
The questioner : Now, if he makes it up, for example, as a mutamatti', or if he makes it up as an ifrad, is the blood of the tamattu' obligatory upon him? No, it is not obligatory upon him because he did not perform tamattu'. However, we say: it is obligatory for you to make it up as a mutamatti', because Hajj al-tamattu' is better than Hajj al-ifrad.
The questioner : If he is unable to perform tamattu'?
The Shaykh : If he is unable to perform tamattu', there is nothing upon him; he becomes an ifrad and there is nothing upon him.