The Ruling on Taking the Spoils in Makkah and al-Madinah
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
What is the ruling on taking the spoils in Makkah and al-Madinah? Or in al-Madinah alone?
Answer:
In al-Madinah only. In Makkah, it is the penalty, whereas in al-Madinah, it is only the spoils.
Q: What if one cannot take the spoils except by resistance?
A: It is not obligatory. If it is facilitated, then it is not obligatory; otherwise, it is not obligatory. However, Sa'd (may Allah be pleased with him) loved to take it, saying: "It is a war spoil." Otherwise, if he left it, it is his right if he permits it.
Q: Is the command for recommendation?
A: It is for permissibility and punishment: permissibility for the taker, and punishment for the aggressor.
Q: Is a car analogous to this?
A: It is a matter of consideration. The closer view is that there is no analogy, because it is more severe and more dangerous.
What is the ruling on taking the spoils in Makkah and al-Madinah? Or in al-Madinah alone?
Answer:
In al-Madinah only. In Makkah, it is the penalty, whereas in al-Madinah, it is only the spoils.
Q: What if one cannot take the spoils except by resistance?
A: It is not obligatory. If it is facilitated, then it is not obligatory; otherwise, it is not obligatory. However, Sa'd (may Allah be pleased with him) loved to take it, saying: "It is a war spoil." Otherwise, if he left it, it is his right if he permits it.
Q: Is the command for recommendation
He has his spoils
فله سلبهA: It is for permissibility and punishment: permissibility for the taker, and punishment for the aggressor.
Q: Is a car analogous to this?
A: It is a matter of consideration. The closer view is that there is no analogy, because it is more severe and more dangerous.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.