The ruling on performing Hajj again for one who doubts about his first Hajj
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The questioner, Umm Abdullah, says: Some women say that their first Hajj did not satisfy them, as they performed it in previous years, and they see that they should repeat it because of the many mistakes that occurred in those previous years. Does their first Hajj suffice them?
Answer:
Voluntary Hajj is sought; whether one performs it once or twice, it is all sought, praise be to Allah. As for the first Hajj, it must be looked into. She has to clarify the reasons that caused confusion for her so that it can be examined. As for her claim that it is valid, or that it is not valid, we do not know the unseen; only Allah knows the unseen. But she has to clarify what difficulties she encountered so that she can be answered. Yes.
The presenter: May Allah reward you.
The questioner, Umm Abdullah, says: Some women say that their first Hajj did not satisfy them, as they performed it in previous years, and they see that they should repeat it because of the many mistakes that occurred in those previous years. Does their first Hajj suffice them?
Answer:
Voluntary Hajj is sought; whether one performs it once or twice, it is all sought, praise be to Allah. As for the first Hajj, it must be looked into. She has to clarify the reasons that caused confusion for her so that it can be examined. As for her claim that it is valid, or that it is not valid, we do not know the unseen; only Allah knows the unseen. But she has to clarify what difficulties she encountered so that she can be answered. Yes.
The presenter: May Allah reward you.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.