What is the ruling on what some Christians do by shooting the sacrificial animal before slaughtering it?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The second point.
The Shaykh : Which one?
The questioner : The second point is that they shoot it, and it dies before the slaughter.
The Shaykh : Yes, that is it, it is forbidden.
Another questioner : If it dies.
Another questioner : It is forbidden.
The Shaykh : He is saying: it died.
The questioner : ... the brothers who are asking, all of them, truly we have prolonged the topic.
The Shaykh: Yes, by Allah.
The questioner : Regarding the brothers who are asking about the topic specifically, if there is ... my question that I want to direct is: is there ... in the method of slaughter or the slaughterer? How, I mean, for all the questioners, either he says perhaps the one who reported it saw it once, and something else happens regarding ... .
Another questioner : As long as, my Shaykh.
The questioner : I want to know why, I want to know why, do not tell me why, I am giving you the answer from one of the Shaykhs ... .
Another questioner : ... .
The questioner : ... there is doubt in it.
Another questioner : No, there is no doubt.
The questioner : Tell me: I went once, and ten, and twenty, and without an appointment, and they did not know that I had gone, and I was watching from a distance, I was observing these sacrificial animals ... the knife of the Minister of Supply ... .
Another questioner : Fine; let me prove to you that even.
The questioner : Germs, these are.
Another questioner : Let me prove to you the observation that I asked about the English, I tell you that some of the sacrificial animals die and their blood does not flow, and they are slaughtered with a knife, they are cut.
...
The Shaykh : And if you cut off your speech, if you want to get rid of Shaykh Ali, throw his minister at him, tell him: was your minister a liar?
Another questioner : No, how can my minister be a liar, professor?
The Shaykh : Then why are you defending yourself? He is telling you!!
Another questioner : What does the minister say ... .
The Shaykh : It has been established that it is not correct, so it remains according to the Islamic method, and you are insisting ... on the Islamic method.
Another questioner : With the knife.
The Shaykh : This is the Islamic Shari'ah with the knife, what would it be? This is the Islamic method, that is what it means.
Another questioner : By Allah, my minister is a bigger liar than this!!
Another questioner : This is within the job, and this is outside the job.
The Shaykh : Doctor, do you know how the shoulder is eaten? This is the truth of the minister now.
The questioner : Did the process of letting the blood flow have confirmation from him ... your opinion?
The Shaykh : No.
Another questioner : I am speaking to the one holding it in my hand, I am asking him, he tells me that some of the sacrificial animals die from ... the electric one or from the shot.
Another questioner : I asked him once, no problem ... the electricity, we asked the Shaykh this question about the shot; so if ... the shot is quick so that the blood flows ... .
Another questioner : ... this is what I am saying, that some of the sacrificial animals ... do not flow ... .
Another questioner : ... .
Another questioner : Allow me, exactly; that it dies as a result of the shot or ... the electric one before the slaughter, I intended one matter; that all these conditions, one of them has doubt in it; soSunan an-Nasa'i 5711Sahih (Darussalam) .
...
The questioner : ... the state is communist, but the general population in "Bulgaria" and "Romania"; so what can we say about ... we generalized a little while ago to the other peoples ... .
Another questioner : The overwhelming majority.
The questioner : Their majority means ... Allah knows best, from the people of the Hijaz.
The Shaykh : What is this, what is this?
The questioner : I mean the slaughterer, for me the slaughterer ... .
The Shaykh : Turks, Turks, we did not talk about that hour!
The questioner : That it?
Another questioner : In the majority, O Shaykh.
The Shaykh : Where were you? Were you sleeping?
The questioner : No, I was not sleeping, I am awake with you, it is none of my business and none of the Turks' business, professor?
The Shaykh : Am I speaking about the Turks? I spoke about the Germans, I spoke about the British, I spoke about all the Christians.
The questioner : No, in "Romania," "Britain" and "Germany" we say the doubt in it is less, professor!
The Shaykh : Thank you, it means you are establishing the argument against yourself!
The questioner : No, "Germany and" "Britain" I say: the doubt in it is less than in "Bulgaria".
The Shaykh : ... the doubt is stronger in ... .
...
The Shaykh : Which one?
The questioner : The second point is that they shoot it, and it dies before the slaughter.
The Shaykh : Yes, that is it, it is forbidden.
Another questioner : If it dies.
Another questioner : It is forbidden.
The Shaykh : He is saying: it died.
The questioner : ... the brothers who are asking, all of them, truly we have prolonged the topic.
The Shaykh: Yes, by Allah.
The questioner : Regarding the brothers who are asking about the topic specifically, if there is ... my question that I want to direct is: is there ... in the method of slaughter or the slaughterer? How, I mean, for all the questioners, either he says perhaps the one who reported it saw it once, and something else happens regarding ... .
Another questioner : As long as, my Shaykh.
The questioner : I want to know why, I want to know why, do not tell me why, I am giving you the answer from one of the Shaykhs ... .
Another questioner : ... .
The questioner : ... there is doubt in it.
Another questioner : No, there is no doubt.
The questioner : Tell me: I went once, and ten, and twenty, and without an appointment, and they did not know that I had gone, and I was watching from a distance, I was observing these sacrificial animals ... the knife of the Minister of Supply ... .
Another questioner : Fine; let me prove to you that even.
The questioner : Germs, these are.
Another questioner : Let me prove to you the observation that I asked about the English, I tell you that some of the sacrificial animals die and their blood does not flow, and they are slaughtered with a knife, they are cut.
...
The Shaykh : And if you cut off your speech, if you want to get rid of Shaykh Ali, throw his minister at him, tell him: was your minister a liar?
Another questioner : No, how can my minister be a liar, professor?
The Shaykh : Then why are you defending yourself? He is telling you!!
Another questioner : What does the minister say ... .
The Shaykh : It has been established that it is not correct, so it remains according to the Islamic method, and you are insisting ... on the Islamic method.
Another questioner : With the knife.
The Shaykh : This is the Islamic Shari'ah with the knife, what would it be? This is the Islamic method, that is what it means.
Another questioner : By Allah, my minister is a bigger liar than this!!
Another questioner : This is within the job, and this is outside the job.
The Shaykh : Doctor, do you know how the shoulder is eaten? This is the truth of the minister now.
The questioner : Did the process of letting the blood flow have confirmation from him ... your opinion?
The Shaykh : No.
Another questioner : I am speaking to the one holding it in my hand, I am asking him, he tells me that some of the sacrificial animals die from ... the electric one or from the shot.
Another questioner : I asked him once, no problem ... the electricity, we asked the Shaykh this question about the shot; so if ... the shot is quick so that the blood flows ... .
Another questioner : ... this is what I am saying, that some of the sacrificial animals ... do not flow ... .
Another questioner : ... .
Another questioner : Allow me, exactly; that it dies as a result of the shot or ... the electric one before the slaughter, I intended one matter; that all these conditions, one of them has doubt in it; so
Leave that which makes you doubt for that which does not make you doubt.
دَعْ ما يريبك إلى ما لا يريبك...
The questioner : ... the state is communist, but the general population in "Bulgaria" and "Romania"; so what can we say about ... we generalized a little while ago to the other peoples ... .
Another questioner : The overwhelming majority.
The questioner : Their majority means ... Allah knows best, from the people of the Hijaz.
The Shaykh : What is this, what is this?
The questioner : I mean the slaughterer, for me the slaughterer ... .
The Shaykh : Turks, Turks, we did not talk about that hour!
The questioner : That it?
Another questioner : In the majority, O Shaykh.
The Shaykh : Where were you? Were you sleeping?
The questioner : No, I was not sleeping, I am awake with you, it is none of my business and none of the Turks' business, professor?
The Shaykh : Am I speaking about the Turks? I spoke about the Germans, I spoke about the British, I spoke about all the Christians.
The questioner : No, in "Romania," "Britain" and "Germany" we say the doubt in it is less, professor!
The Shaykh : Thank you, it means you are establishing the argument against yourself!
The questioner : No, "Germany and" "Britain" I say: the doubt in it is less than in "Bulgaria".
The Shaykh : ... the doubt is stronger in ... .
...
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.