The Place of Saying: (Ameen) in the Prayer
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The place of saying: (Ameen) in the prayer]
The hadith of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), which is the ameen of the believers in Surat al-Fatihah,For example, the imam says: and not those who go astray,And the ma'mum naturally says: Amen,So I do not know if the imam says: Amen,Then the ma'mums respond behind him: Amen,Or if he says: and not those who go astray,They said: Ameen?The Shaykh: When he says: and not those who go astray,They said: Amen.
The questioner: Even though Shaykh Al-Albani says: No, this is contrary to it.
First: May Allah bless you! We do not allow anyone to mention a specific scholar to us.
And it is only for you to say: Some scholars said, but as for so-and-so and so-and-so, you never mention them to us; we do not want that.
But if it is Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) who narrated: (When the imam says ameen, then say ameen), it is he who narrated: (When the imam says: and not those who go astray,Say: ameen), and on this basis, the meaning of his saying: when he says ameen,Meaning: when he reaches the place of ameen, which is his saying: (and not those who go astray), or when he says ameen, meaning: when he begins to say ameen, then say ameen. The meaning is not: when he finishes saying ameen, then say ameen. So the hadith explains part of itself,If this hadith is narrated: (When he says: and not those who go astray,Say: ameen), we know the meaning of his saying: (When he says ameen, then say ameen), that the intended meaning is: when he reaches the place of ameen, or when he begins to say ameen, then say ameen with him.
The hadith of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), which is the ameen of the believers in Surat al-Fatihah,For example, the imam says: and not those who go astray,And the ma'mum naturally says: Amen,So I do not know if the imam says: Amen,Then the ma'mums respond behind him: Amen,Or if he says: and not those who go astray,They said: Ameen?The Shaykh: When he says: and not those who go astray,They said: Amen.
The questioner: Even though Shaykh Al-Albani says: No, this is contrary to it.
First: May Allah bless you! We do not allow anyone to mention a specific scholar to us.
And it is only for you to say: Some scholars said, but as for so-and-so and so-and-so, you never mention them to us; we do not want that.
But if it is Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) who narrated: (When the imam says ameen, then say ameen), it is he who narrated: (When the imam says: and not those who go astray,Say: ameen), and on this basis, the meaning of his saying: when he says ameen,Meaning: when he reaches the place of ameen, which is his saying: (and not those who go astray), or when he says ameen, meaning: when he begins to say ameen, then say ameen. The meaning is not: when he finishes saying ameen, then say ameen. So the hadith explains part of itself,If this hadith is narrated: (When he says: and not those who go astray,Say: ameen), we know the meaning of his saying: (When he says ameen, then say ameen), that the intended meaning is: when he reaches the place of ameen, or when he begins to say ameen, then say ameen with him.