A student informs the Shaykh about a discussion that took place between him and a person on a day in Ramadan regarding which there was disagreement about fasting

The questioner : And then he asked about fasting, fasting on this day. I said, "By Allah, the people of knowledge say that whoever breaks his fast on this day, then..." I felt, my Shaykh, from this question of his, that I thought he wanted to lure me in, because I say perhaps he knew about the prohibition... so he started to see what my opinion was. I said to him, "By Allah, this day must be fasted." He said to me, "There are people who broke their fast." I said to him, "Those who broke their fast must—according to the people of knowledge—make up this day." He said, "What did Saudi Arabia say?" I said, "No, we are not [bound by that], meaning we have our own specific sighting now for this."