Is the narration regarding scraping semen from the garment authentic? Is scraping obligatory or not? Does scraping indicate the impurity of semen?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Regarding the command to scrape in the case of semen, I am with... The al-Hafiz authenticates the hadith, but I found that it is anomalous (shadh), the hadith, because it is connected through several narrations without the command to scrape except this narration here, and... regarding scraping. It appeared to me while I was, meaning, studying that I found it to be anomalous, so I do not know.
The Shaykh : Who narrated the command?
The questioner : Yes?
The Shaykh : Who narrated the command?
The questioner : I do not know.
Another questioner: Did you understand how?
The Shaykh : Aisha is the one who narrated the hadith of semen, but with many wordings. So who narrated the wording of the command?
The questioner : By Allah... scraping, I did not err because of...
The Shaykh : ... .
The questioner : Ibn Hazm weakens it, but I found, while tracking all the narrations, meaning, gathering them... I have all the narrations, and we have this narration whose narrators differ among us, so...
Another questioner: But it is not possible.
The questioner : Meaning, he... the command to scrape, even if we were commanded to scrape, is it possible that impurity follows from it, or is it possible? Suppose the hadith of the command to scrape is correct, do we remain with the command to scrape, or with... the impurity?
The Shaykh : No, if the wording of the command is established and it is established that the command is for obligation, then it is established that it is impure.
The questioner : This requires specific research.
The Shaykh : Yes, welcome, Abu 'Adnan... How are you?
The Shaykh : Who narrated the command?
The questioner : Yes?
The Shaykh : Who narrated the command?
The questioner : I do not know.
Another questioner: Did you understand how?
The Shaykh : Aisha is the one who narrated the hadith of semen, but with many wordings. So who narrated the wording of the command?
The questioner : By Allah... scraping, I did not err because of...
The Shaykh : ... .
The questioner : Ibn Hazm weakens it, but I found, while tracking all the narrations, meaning, gathering them... I have all the narrations, and we have this narration whose narrators differ among us, so...
Another questioner: But it is not possible.
The questioner : Meaning, he... the command to scrape, even if we were commanded to scrape, is it possible that impurity follows from it, or is it possible? Suppose the hadith of the command to scrape is correct, do we remain with the command to scrape, or with... the impurity?
The Shaykh : No, if the wording of the command is established and it is established that the command is for obligation, then it is established that it is impure.
The questioner : This requires specific research.
The Shaykh : Yes, welcome, Abu 'Adnan... How are you?