(The Denialist’s Prioritization of Reason over Transmission) Reason is the root of transmission and its father; if *** you invalidate it, its lower branch is invalidated, so it is necessary to employ the rational and ***
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : He said:
"Reason is the root of transmission and its father; if *** you invalidate it, its lower branch is invalidated
so it is necessary to employ the rational and *** the abrogation of the transmitted by law by proof".
By proof, is that so? Fine ... .
The student: ... .
The Shaykh :"and the abrogation of the transmitted by proof". So the law extends the verse a bit.
"by proof"
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Not by proof.
"so it is necessary to employ the rational and *** the abrogation of the transmitted by proof" Fine.
He says: The reason is that we do not abrogate the rational, but we abrogate the transmitted. The reason, he said, is because reason is the root of transmission. Reason is the root of transmission and its father; if you invalidate it, the branch is invalidated. If you invalidate the reason that is the root of transmission, the branch is invalidated. This is what they claim ... So if the matter is thus
"so it is necessary to employ the rational and the abrogation of the transmitted by proof".
"Reason is the root of transmission and its father; if *** you invalidate it, its lower branch is invalidated
so it is necessary to employ the rational and *** the abrogation of the transmitted by law by proof".
By proof, is that so? Fine ... .
The student: ... .
The Shaykh :"and the abrogation of the transmitted by proof". So the law extends the verse a bit.
"by proof"
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : Not by proof.
"so it is necessary to employ the rational and *** the abrogation of the transmitted by proof" Fine.
He says: The reason is that we do not abrogate the rational, but we abrogate the transmitted. The reason, he said, is because reason is the root of transmission. Reason is the root of transmission and its father; if you invalidate it, the branch is invalidated. If you invalidate the reason that is the root of transmission, the branch is invalidated. This is what they claim ... So if the matter is thus
"so it is necessary to employ the rational and the abrogation of the transmitted by proof".
