The Meaning of the Poet's Statement: "So the denial in one of the two premises is known in its explanation, without any denial, whether the denial is in the necessity or in the negation of the necessary consequence attributed to invalidity"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :
"So the denial in one of the two premises is known in its explanation, therefore without any denial"
May Allah have mercy on him. Regarding one of the two premises, we say: If affirming the attributes necessitates ascribing a body to Allah, then is that correct and true? And if it does not necessitate it, then your disparagement of us is a lie and slander. It must be either this or that. Glory be to Allah! He says:
"The denial is either in the necessity or in the negation of the necessary consequence attributed to invalidity"
The denial is either in the necessity, and what does "in the necessity" mean? It means we say that this is not a necessary consequence; it is not a necessary consequence. If you compel us to accept it, it is still not a necessary consequence. Or it is the negation of the necessary consequence attributed to invalidity, meaning we say it is a necessary consequence, but it is not invalid. We deny the necessary consequence that is attributed to invalidity. Good.
"So the denial in one of the two premises is known in its explanation, therefore without any denial"
May Allah have mercy on him. Regarding one of the two premises, we say: If affirming the attributes necessitates ascribing a body to Allah, then is that correct and true? And if it does not necessitate it, then your disparagement of us is a lie and slander. It must be either this or that. Glory be to Allah! He says:
"The denial is either in the necessity or in the negation of the necessary consequence attributed to invalidity"
The denial is either in the necessity, and what does "in the necessity" mean? It means we say that this is not a necessary consequence; it is not a necessary consequence. If you compel us to accept it, it is still not a necessary consequence. Or it is the negation of the necessary consequence attributed to invalidity, meaning we say it is a necessary consequence, but it is not invalid. We deny the necessary consequence that is attributed to invalidity. Good.