Especially if it is not obligatory, *** but he thinks it is obligatory in his mind (I'rab of "ma" and the meaning of "siyama")
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"Especially if it is not obligatory *** but he thinks it is obligatory in his mind"
"Siyama" means "especially" if it is, if it is not obligatory. If it is, this "ma" is superfluous. And the one who says: "O seeker, take the benefit: the 'ma' after 'idha' is superfluous", repeat the verse for me. Yes, the other one, you.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : No.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : The "ma" after "ma" is superfluous. The one who was present at the beginning, do you need it? Yes, the one who was not present at the beginning, come on.
The student: "O seeker, take the benefit: the 'ma' after 'idha' is superfluous"
The Shaykh : That is right, meaning if "ma" comes after "idha," it is superfluous. Allah the Exalted said:[Ash-Shuraa 42:37] meaning until they came to it. Now, here the author (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
"Especially if it is not obligatory" means especially if it is, if it is not obligatory.
"But he thinks it is obligatory in his mind".
"Siyama" means "especially" if it is, if it is not obligatory. If it is, this "ma" is superfluous. And the one who says: "O seeker, take the benefit: the 'ma' after 'idha' is superfluous", repeat the verse for me. Yes, the other one, you.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : No.
The student: ... .
The Shaykh : The "ma" after "ma" is superfluous. The one who was present at the beginning, do you need it? Yes, the one who was not present at the beginning, come on.
The student: "O seeker, take the benefit: the 'ma' after 'idha' is superfluous"
The Shaykh : That is right, meaning if "ma" comes after "idha," it is superfluous. Allah the Exalted said:
and when they are angry, they forgive,
وإذا ما غضبوا هم يغفرونUntil when they came to it, they testified against him
حتى إذا ما جاؤوها شهدوا عليه"Especially if it is not obligatory" means especially if it is, if it is not obligatory.
"But he thinks it is obligatory in his mind".