Or was he alive but unable to speak? *** And unable to answer a heedless questioner, and unable to move? So what is the life that you have affirmed? Clarify it with an explanation.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"Or was he alive but unable to speak? *** And unable to answer a heedless questioner,
and unable to move? So what is the life that you have affirmed? Clarify it with an explanation."
That is to say, if you say that he is alive but cannot speak and cannot move, we say to you: What kind of life was it? What kind was it? Therefore, it must be that the life, even if he is alive in his grave, is a life distinct from the life of this world in any case.
"This, and why did not his companions come to him *** complaining of the wrath of the"
Yes, I think the time has ended, and Allah knows best.
The student : A chapter on the discussion of the life of the prophets
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, to.
The student : If he was alive but unable.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, yes.
and unable to move? So what is the life that you have affirmed? Clarify it with an explanation."
That is to say, if you say that he is alive but cannot speak and cannot move, we say to you: What kind of life was it? What kind was it? Therefore, it must be that the life, even if he is alive in his grave, is a life distinct from the life of this world in any case.
"This, and why did not his companions come to him *** complaining of the wrath of the"
Yes, I think the time has ended, and Allah knows best.
The student : A chapter on the discussion of the life of the prophets
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, to.
The student : If he was alive but unable.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes, yes.