Do you think he testifies to their opinion and their disagreement? *** And is he one who conceals the clarification? If you say the clarification preceded, you have spoken the truth *** For he was one who showed kindness through repetition
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"Do you think he testifies to their opinion and their disagreement? *** And is he one who conceals the clarification?"
What is the answer? No, it is not possible. All of this indicates that he is not alive in his grave as he was alive in this world, because if he were alive as he was in this world, they would have referred to him in these matters.
"If you say the clarification preceded, you have spoken the truth *** For he was one who showed kindness through repetition"
Yes, if they said: The reason the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) did not do that is because he had already provided the clear clarification and left his community on a straight, white path, we would say: You have spoken the truth. He did clarify and left his community on the straight, white path. But what harm would it do him to repeat the clarification? Repeating the clarification would be an increase of kindness to the community. For this reason, he said:
"If you say the clarification preceded" meaning there is no need for it, "you have spoken the truth ***"
This is the answer to the "if"
"*** For he was one who showed kindness through repetition"
Meaning, if he had repeated it, it would have been an increase of good and kindness for the community.
What is the answer? No, it is not possible. All of this indicates that he is not alive in his grave as he was alive in this world, because if he were alive as he was in this world, they would have referred to him in these matters.
"If you say the clarification preceded, you have spoken the truth *** For he was one who showed kindness through repetition"
Yes, if they said: The reason the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) did not do that is because he had already provided the clear clarification and left his community on a straight, white path, we would say: You have spoken the truth. He did clarify and left his community on the straight, white path. But what harm would it do him to repeat the clarification? Repeating the clarification would be an increase of kindness to the community. For this reason, he said:
"If you say the clarification preceded" meaning there is no need for it, "you have spoken the truth ***"
This is the answer to the "if"
"*** For he was one who showed kindness through repetition"
Meaning, if he had repeated it, it would have been an increase of good and kindness for the community.