(Explanation of the Ta'tilah's claim that the entire Qur'an, both its wording and its meaning, is created) O Lord, they have said that in the mushafs of ***Islam, there is nothing of the Qur'an except
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : The author (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
"O Lord, they have said that in the mushafs of ***Islam, there is nothing of the Qur'an"
Meaning: These people of ta'til (denial of the divine attributes) say that in the mushafs, there is nothing of the Qur'an
"except the ink and these sheets of paper *** and the leather that has been flayed from an animal
and all of it is created"
They say: What is between the covers of the mushaf is created. Why? Because it is ink, meaning dye, written with a pen on paper. The pen, the ink, and the paper, yes, are created. So he says: This which is between us of the Qur'an is this ink.
"except the ink and these sheets of paper *** and the leather that has been flayed from an animal"
"O Lord, they have said that in the mushafs of ***Islam, there is nothing of the Qur'an"
Meaning: These people of ta'til (denial of the divine attributes) say that in the mushafs, there is nothing of the Qur'an
"except the ink and these sheets of paper *** and the leather that has been flayed from an animal
and all of it is created"
They say: What is between the covers of the mushaf is created. Why? Because it is ink, meaning dye, written with a pen on paper. The pen, the ink, and the paper, yes, are created. So he says: This which is between us of the Qur'an is this ink.
"except the ink and these sheets of paper *** and the leather that has been flayed from an animal"