(Explanation of the Necessary Implication of the Ta'til Doctrine) If a man were to trample it, they would say he did not tread *** except the ink and the paper, O Lord, the sanctity of the Qur'an has vanished from *** those hearts
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh :"If a man were to trample it, they would say he did not tread *** except the ink and the paper"
This means: If someone were to take the mushaf and trample it with his foot, they would say: He does not commit disbelief, because he did not trample the words of Allah, but rather he trampled the ink and the paper. And trampling the ink and the paper? There is nothing wrong with that. So look how this false statement leads to this false implication. I believe that if someone were to trample the mushaf in front of the common people, they would tear it to pieces before he lifted his foot from the mushaf, and it is impossible for them to say that this man did not trample anything but the paper and the ink, ever. But this implication is false, and if the implication is false, the premise is false. All right.
"O Lord, the sanctity of the Qur'an has vanished from *** those hearts and the sanctity of faith"
This means: It is necessary, according to their statement, that the sanctity of the Qur'an and the sanctity of faith vanish, and this is clear.
"O Lord"
Yes.
This means: If someone were to take the mushaf and trample it with his foot, they would say: He does not commit disbelief, because he did not trample the words of Allah, but rather he trampled the ink and the paper. And trampling the ink and the paper? There is nothing wrong with that. So look how this false statement leads to this false implication. I believe that if someone were to trample the mushaf in front of the common people, they would tear it to pieces before he lifted his foot from the mushaf, and it is impossible for them to say that this man did not trample anything but the paper and the ink, ever. But this implication is false, and if the implication is false, the premise is false. All right.
"O Lord, the sanctity of the Qur'an has vanished from *** those hearts and the sanctity of faith"
This means: It is necessary, according to their statement, that the sanctity of the Qur'an and the sanctity of faith vanish, and this is clear.
"O Lord"
Yes.