What is your response to the claim of some scholars that the hadith: (Keep him away from the black) is a specific case and has no generality?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Some scholars ... that ... the black is permissible ... This is a specific case, meaning it is not ... to specify it ... ?
The Shaykh : ... , this is not correct, because is not a specific case. He also said that changing the white is a specific case, because the statement was made in a single manner.
And it is known -changing the white is my intention- and it is known that changing the white is general, as in this hadith with us, it is not specific to Abu Qahafah.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : It is attributed to them as an excuse that they thought the hadith was general, and his saying did not reach them: . And there is a good paper by Shaykh Faris ibn Bahil on this topic, in which he clarified that the hadith is authentic and it is because some claimed that it was inserted. Yes.
Keep away from black.
جنبوه السوادThe Shaykh : ... , this is not correct, because
Keep away from black.
جنبوه السوادAnd it is known -changing the white is my intention- and it is known that changing the white is general, as in this hadith with us, it is not specific to Abu Qahafah.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : It is attributed to them as an excuse that they thought the hadith was general, and his saying did not reach them:
