What is your opinion regarding a group who pray in a mosque and rely on the adhan from another nearby mosque, where the other mosque has an early adhan?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : What is your esteemed opinion regarding a group who pray in a mosque and rely on the adhan from another nearby mosque, where the other mosque has a loudspeaker?
The Shaykh : It appears he is asking whether this mosque does not have an adhan for some of the obligatory prayers. As for the validity of the prayer, it is valid if there is a mu'adhdhin whose adhan can be heard by the people of the neighborhood, even if he is not in their neighborhood; this adhan suffices for them. However, for a mosque where the congregation is established at every time to have no mu'adhdhin is contrary to what is customary and contrary to what is common. Perhaps there are people in the neighborhood who wait for the adhan of its mu'adhdhin and are thereby misled. Yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you. The questioner says.
The Shaykh : It appears he is asking whether this mosque does not have an adhan for some of the obligatory prayers. As for the validity of the prayer, it is valid if there is a mu'adhdhin whose adhan can be heard by the people of the neighborhood, even if he is not in their neighborhood; this adhan suffices for them. However, for a mosque where the congregation is established at every time to have no mu'adhdhin is contrary to what is customary and contrary to what is common. Perhaps there are people in the neighborhood who wait for the adhan of its mu'adhdhin and are thereby misled. Yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you. The questioner says.