Explanation of the author's statement: "And if they deny it or drop it, it is dropped."
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : The author said "And if they deny it". How did he say "deny it" in terms of morphology, without saying "deny it" with a waw? It is a yaa, is it not? Do we not say "they denied such and such"? They denied such and such.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Oh Allah, O 'Abd Allah?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Okay, the question of 'Abd Allah is: is it not said "they denied such and such" with a waw? How do you say it with a yaa?
The questioner : ... He said he denies.
The Shaykh : Even if he said he denies, or even if he said they denied?
The questioner : Its root is "he denied."
The Shaykh : Its root is "he denied" and "they denied"?
The questioner : They denied ... the waw is for the group.
The Shaykh : Well done. The waw here is not the waw of the verb, but the waw of the group, a pronoun. Okay, in any case, the expression "if they deny it" is correct. Okay, "if they deny it" means they denied the option, and the way to deny it is for them to agree that there is no option between them. He said, "Look, I am selling to you, but you see there is no option between us." He said, "No problem, I accept." Then the option is dropped, and the contract becomes binding simply by the offer and acceptance, meaning simply by saying "I sold to you" and the other saying "I accepted, there is no option."
"Or they dropped it". It was dropped. When? After the contract, meaning after the contract was completed and one or two minutes or ten minutes had passed, and they agreed to drop the option, then it is dropped.
The reasoning? Because the right belongs to them, so if they agree to drop it, it is dropped. If someone says, "This condition forbids what Allah has made lawful, because Allah has made it lawful for each of them to rescind, so if they condition that there is no option or drop it, this is forbidding what Allah has made lawful," we say that this prohibition is not for the right of Allah, but for the right of the human being, and the matter of the human being's right is up to him. So if they drop it or deny it with the contract, whether they drop it after the contract or deny it with the contract, there is no harm.
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Oh Allah, O 'Abd Allah?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh : Okay, the question of 'Abd Allah is: is it not said "they denied such and such" with a waw? How do you say it with a yaa?
The questioner : ... He said he denies.
The Shaykh : Even if he said he denies, or even if he said they denied?
The questioner : Its root is "he denied."
The Shaykh : Its root is "he denied" and "they denied"?
The questioner : They denied ... the waw is for the group.
The Shaykh : Well done. The waw here is not the waw of the verb, but the waw of the group, a pronoun. Okay, in any case, the expression "if they deny it" is correct. Okay, "if they deny it" means they denied the option, and the way to deny it is for them to agree that there is no option between them. He said, "Look, I am selling to you, but you see there is no option between us." He said, "No problem, I accept." Then the option is dropped, and the contract becomes binding simply by the offer and acceptance, meaning simply by saying "I sold to you" and the other saying "I accepted, there is no option."
"Or they dropped it". It was dropped. When? After the contract, meaning after the contract was completed and one or two minutes or ten minutes had passed, and they agreed to drop the option, then it is dropped.
The reasoning? Because the right belongs to them, so if they agree to drop it, it is dropped. If someone says, "This condition forbids what Allah has made lawful, because Allah has made it lawful for each of them to rescind, so if they condition that there is no option or drop it, this is forbidding what Allah has made lawful," we say that this prohibition is not for the right of Allah, but for the right of the human being, and the matter of the human being's right is up to him. So if they drop it or deny it with the contract, whether they drop it after the contract or deny it with the contract, there is no harm.