Permissibility of taking pebbles from other than Muzdalifah
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
May Allah reward you with good. In fact, he was going to ask this question, may Allah reward you. His fourth question says: If the pebbles taken from Muzdalifah for the stoning of the Jamarat al-Aqabah are insufficient, may they be taken from other than Muzdalifah or not? May Allah guide you.
Answer: It has been mentioned previously what indicates this, and that taking them from Muzdalifah is not obligatory. If he takes them from Muzdalifah and throws them, and then takes others from Mina, that is sufficient. So if he takes seven from Muzdalifah and some fall, he takes from Mina, praise be to Allah. There is no need for him to carry them with him; throwing them from Mina is sufficient.
Answer: It has been mentioned previously what indicates this, and that taking them from Muzdalifah is not obligatory. If he takes them from Muzdalifah and throws them, and then takes others from Mina, that is sufficient. So if he takes seven from Muzdalifah and some fall, he takes from Mina, praise be to Allah. There is no need for him to carry them with him; throwing them from Mina is sufficient.
Source
binbaz.org.sa
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.
