Discussion regarding those who say that the stones for stoning must be taken from Muzdalifah.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : Also, regarding this matter, they take stones from Muzdalifah and believe that stoning the pillars is not valid unless the stones are from Muzdalifah. This is a mistake, and taking the stones from Muzdalifah is not a recommended practice. Take the stones from any place.
Then, some of them also take stones and add pebbles to them, and they forget and bring them to their country. Then they ask and say: Is it permissible to throw them on the ground? What do you say? Or we say: Go, travel by plane so that you can throw them in Mina. They believe this. We explain to them that if you forget stones from the pillars in your pocket, throw them in any place.
Then, some of them also take stones and add pebbles to them, and they forget and bring them to their country. Then they ask and say: Is it permissible to throw them on the ground? What do you say? Or we say: Go, travel by plane so that you can throw them in Mina. They believe this. We explain to them that if you forget stones from the pillars in your pocket, throw them in any place.