The issue of whether minor shirk falls under the will of Allah
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Regarding minor shirk, does it fall under the will of Allah (Glorified and Exalted is He)?
There was a disagreement among the scholars regarding it: -Some of them said: It falls under the will; if Allah wills, He will forgive him.
-And some of them said: He must be punished, but he will not remain in the Fire eternally.
In any case: Even if we say that it is under the will, is a person guaranteed that Allah wills to forgive him? He is not guaranteed. Even sins other than shirk, which are undoubtedly under the will, a person is not permitted to be negligent with them on the basis that they are under the will; because the original ruling is that the punishment occurs.
There was a disagreement among the scholars regarding it: -Some of them said: It falls under the will; if Allah wills, He will forgive him.
-And some of them said: He must be punished, but he will not remain in the Fire eternally.
In any case: Even if we say that it is under the will, is a person guaranteed that Allah wills to forgive him? He is not guaranteed. Even sins other than shirk, which are undoubtedly under the will, a person is not permitted to be negligent with them on the basis that they are under the will; because the original ruling is that the punishment occurs.