The Time for Stoning the Pillars
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner: Some people say that stoning the pillars is done at night because the time has not yet ended. So, when does the time for stoning the pillars end?
Those who say: The time for stoning extends until the dawn of the second day. They say that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) specified its beginning but did not specify its end, and that what is permissible at the beginning of the night is permissible at the end of the night, just as standing at 'Arafah is. It is known that the Day of 'Arafah ends with the setting of the sun, but the night of the festival, which is the night of the tenth, follows the day before it, the ninth day.So he said: This is similar to it.
And some people say: One should stone at night only until its midpoint. Their evidence for this is that a man asked the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), saying: (I stoned after it had become evening,He said: there is no harm). They say that the evening lasts from the last half of the day to the end of the first half of the night.
And what appears to me is that the statement: That it extends until the dawn is closer to the truth.
Those who say: The time for stoning extends until the dawn of the second day. They say that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) specified its beginning but did not specify its end, and that what is permissible at the beginning of the night is permissible at the end of the night, just as standing at 'Arafah is. It is known that the Day of 'Arafah ends with the setting of the sun, but the night of the festival, which is the night of the tenth, follows the day before it, the ninth day.So he said: This is similar to it.
And some people say: One should stone at night only until its midpoint. Their evidence for this is that a man asked the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), saying: (I stoned after it had become evening,He said: there is no harm). They say that the evening lasts from the last half of the day to the end of the first half of the night.
And what appears to me is that the statement: That it extends until the dawn is closer to the truth.
