Is there a disagreement among the scholars regarding ifrad?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : You mentioned that Hajj is divided into three categories. You mentioned ifrad. Is there a disagreement among the scholars regarding ifrad?
The Shaykh : Some scholars say: Tamattu' is obligatory, and Qiran is not permissible except with bringing the sacrificial animal, and Ifrad is not permissible except with bringing the sacrificial animal. However, this opinion is weak. The correct view is that all three types of Hajj are permissible, but they differ in terms of virtue. Tamattu' is the best, Qiran is better for the one who brings the sacrificial animal, and Ifrad is the last of them. Yes.
The Shaykh : Some scholars say: Tamattu' is obligatory, and Qiran is not permissible except with bringing the sacrificial animal, and Ifrad is not permissible except with bringing the sacrificial animal. However, this opinion is weak. The correct view is that all three types of Hajj are permissible, but they differ in terms of virtue. Tamattu' is the best, Qiran is better for the one who brings the sacrificial animal, and Ifrad is the last of them. Yes.