When a person comes to do a good deed and I am afraid of him, I make this supplication: O Allah, make his plot against him. Is this considered transgression in supplication?

The questioner : When a person comes to do a good deed and I am afraid of him, I make this supplication, saying: O Allah, make his plot against him. Is this considered transgression in supplication?

The Shaykh : Yes, it is transgression in supplication, and it is bad suspicion of a Muslim. The default for a Muslim is not to have bad suspicion. However, a person may say, if he fears based on reality: O Allah, if this person intended to plot against me, then make his plot against him. He must condition it.