A discussion on matters of creed.
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner: ... that is: So-and-so came, meaning he came by his own self, or did he come by other than his self?
The Shaykh: No, Allah created ... Allah created ... .
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Allah came, Allah created ... all of it is Allah.
The questioner: What does "by His own self" mean?
The Shaykh : Oh?
The questioner: What does "by His own self" mean?
The Shaykh: What does "by His own self" mean?
The questioner: It is not a rational meaning.
The Shaykh: The general creation.
The questioner: The specific creation with some of His servants, as ... in what came before.
Another questioner: Naturally, regarding those who came before in the matter.
The Shaykh: ... but this is an understanding ... .
The questioner: ... Allah - Glorified and Exalted is He - brought Allah close to His servants.
Another questioner: Naturally, this is a law ... .
The questioner: Naturally, a law that was.
The Shaykh: No, but ... the opposite ... .
Another questioner: I am the one who reviewed it in ... .
The Shaykh: ... the opposite, they said peace.
The questioner: ... - Glorified and Exalted is He - above the Throne, and He is with us by His attributes.
The Shaykh: ... especially this, meaning ... in the general speech ... they said peace ... and I did not count Ibn Taymiyyah's opinion in this, because, did you know of any of the Salaf who opposed this interpretation?
The questioner: In creed there is moderation ... the Book and the Sunnah and consensus; so is it established that there is ... .
The Shaykh: ... you repeat the speech and do not answer the question.
The questioner: The question, I do not know of a problem with it, and I do not know ... its placement.
The Shaykh: He says he knows, do not repeat the question; because we answered you regarding the question.
The questioner: ... agreement.
The Shaykh: Agreement with what in the first place?
The questioner: He says that among the Salaf, those who agreed with him in that, according to what he says.
The Shaykh: Who among the Salaf agreed with you when we asked you, did Allah create the universe? You said: by His own self. Who agreed with you?
The questioner: They all say by ... He is the One who created with His hands ... .
The Shaykh: Created.
The questioner: And they said about Allah.
The Shaykh: Did they say by His own self?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Did they say by His own self? Did Allah create the heavens by His own self? Did they say this?
The questioner : What... .
The Shaykh: Okay; you said.
The questioner : What... .
The Shaykh: You said: Allah created the heavens with His hand.
The questioner: No problem, we made a mistake, let us go back and withdraw the question.
The Shaykh: [ The Shaykh laughs! ] .
The questioner: Let us go back and repeat the question, whether the Salaf said that?
The Shaykh: This is not speech.
The questioner : Yes?
The Shaykh: It is not speech for you to say: every clear matter needs evidence for it from the speech of the Salaf; as proof that when we said to you: Allah created the heavens, what does every Muslim understand in it?
Another questioner: Meaning this ... is not.
The Shaykh: ... will you reconsider when ... .
The Shaykh: No, Allah created ... Allah created ... .
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Allah came, Allah created ... all of it is Allah.
The questioner: What does "by His own self" mean?
The Shaykh : Oh?
The questioner: What does "by His own self" mean?
The Shaykh: What does "by His own self" mean?
The questioner: It is not a rational meaning.
The Shaykh: The general creation.
The questioner: The specific creation with some of His servants, as ... in what came before.
Another questioner: Naturally, regarding those who came before in the matter.
The Shaykh: ... but this is an understanding ... .
The questioner: ... Allah - Glorified and Exalted is He - brought Allah close to His servants.
Another questioner: Naturally, this is a law ... .
The questioner: Naturally, a law that was.
The Shaykh: No, but ... the opposite ... .
Another questioner: I am the one who reviewed it in ... .
The Shaykh: ... the opposite, they said peace.
The questioner: ... - Glorified and Exalted is He - above the Throne, and He is with us by His attributes.
The Shaykh: ... especially this, meaning ... in the general speech ... they said peace ... and I did not count Ibn Taymiyyah's opinion in this, because, did you know of any of the Salaf who opposed this interpretation?
The questioner: In creed there is moderation ... the Book and the Sunnah and consensus; so is it established that there is ... .
The Shaykh: ... you repeat the speech and do not answer the question.
The questioner: The question, I do not know of a problem with it, and I do not know ... its placement.
The Shaykh: He says he knows, do not repeat the question; because we answered you regarding the question.
The questioner: ... agreement.
The Shaykh: Agreement with what in the first place?
The questioner: He says that among the Salaf, those who agreed with him in that, according to what he says.
The Shaykh: Who among the Salaf agreed with you when we asked you, did Allah create the universe? You said: by His own self. Who agreed with you?
The questioner: They all say by ... He is the One who created with His hands ... .
The Shaykh: Created.
The questioner: And they said about Allah.
The Shaykh: Did they say by His own self?
The questioner : ... .
The Shaykh: Did they say by His own self? Did Allah create the heavens by His own self? Did they say this?
The questioner : What... .
The Shaykh: Okay; you said.
The questioner : What... .
The Shaykh: You said: Allah created the heavens with His hand.
The questioner: No problem, we made a mistake, let us go back and withdraw the question.
The Shaykh: [ The Shaykh laughs! ] .
The questioner: Let us go back and repeat the question, whether the Salaf said that?
The Shaykh: This is not speech.
The questioner : Yes?
The Shaykh: It is not speech for you to say: every clear matter needs evidence for it from the speech of the Salaf; as proof that when we said to you: Allah created the heavens, what does every Muslim understand in it?
Another questioner: Meaning this ... is not.
The Shaykh: ... will you reconsider when ... .
Source
www.al-albany.com
The Arabic text is copied verbatim from the original source, without any edits.