If the husband is angry with his wife for a reason other than what is mentioned in the hadith regarding disobedience in the marital bed?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : If the husband spends the night, O Shaykh, angry with his wife over a matter other than this hadith?
The Shaykh : What falls under this? What falls under it? Because this is a specific need. Suppose he said, "Make dinner," and she said, "I am sleepy," and he got angry at her. This can be resolved; he can make it himself or have one of the children make it. But that specific matter there is of no use to anyone but the woman.
The questioner : What if it was at night, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : What if it was at night.
The questioner : What if he called her from the door...
The Shaykh : Cursing is for the one who refuses.
The questioner : What if he called her...!
The Shaykh : No difference.
The Shaykh : What falls under this? What falls under it? Because this is a specific need. Suppose he said, "Make dinner," and she said, "I am sleepy," and he got angry at her. This can be resolved; he can make it himself or have one of the children make it. But that specific matter there is of no use to anyone but the woman.
The questioner : What if it was at night, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : What if it was at night.
The questioner : What if he called her from the door...
The Shaykh : Cursing is for the one who refuses.
The questioner : What if he called her...!
The Shaykh : No difference.