Fatwas of Al-Albani - page 160
Fatwas (page 160 of 296)
- Al-Hakim graded a hadith as authentic, so al-Dhahabi was severe with him, saying, “I said…
- Can al-Hafiz al-Dhahabi’s statement regarding al-Mustadrak (which he has summarized, and…
- What is the criterion in the issue of the conflict between the statement and the action…
- The questioner: The issue of Muhammad ibn 'Ujlan; in the biography of Muhammad ibn 'Ujlan…
- Is a narrator described as "truthful" whose condition changed in his later years included…
- The silence of al-Dhahabi regarding what al-Hakim mentions in al-Mustadrak on the…
- Does the vague plural get corrected in the case of those below the Tabi'un and others?
- It is often the case that al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar quotes the words of al-Hakim and says, “It is…
- Is it a condition for a narration to be classified as *munkar* that the point of…
- Is there anyone who says that al-Hafiz al-Dhahabi’s *Takhmis* was a manuscript on its own…
- Is the statement of al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar, as transmitted by al-Suyuti and from him Ahmad…
- What is the final ruling on describing a narrator who selects among his shaykhs? Does this…
- What is the criterion for a narrator who narrated a hadith in which he contradicted a…
- What is the stronger position regarding the issue of Ibn Jurayj's tadlis (concealment of a…
- If a biography of a narrator mentions that he met his teacher in a clear manner, but we…
- Is there a difference between ("his hadith is recorded but not relied upon" and "weak")?
- The statement of al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar in *al-Nukat* and elsewhere that the narration of…
- Did al-Bukhari require severe weakness in his book of weak narrators, given Ibn Abi…
- What is the definitive position on the issue of using analogical reasoning and scholarly…
- What is the stronger position regarding the definition of a fabricated hadith?
- The statement of al-Hafiz al-Haythami: "Al-Tabarani narrated it in al-Kabir or al-Awsat…
- If a scholar cites a hadith with certainty, is this considered his authentication of it?
- What is the authenticity of the saying of Shu'bah, "I have saved you from the tadlis of…
- What is the validity of the statement of al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar, which he adopted in the…
- Is al-Hakim's statement in al-Mustadrak, "and al-Bukhari and Muslim did not include it," a…
- When is a narration considered anomalous?
- If no one narrates from a narrator except his son, is the existence of the son evidence…
- If a truthful narrator inserts a detail into the narration of a trustworthy narrator, does…
- What is the correct view regarding Urwah’s narration from A’ishah when he narrates from…
- When al-Daraqutni cites a hadith in his book *Al-Ilal* that contradicts the consensus of…
- The condition of meeting in al-Bukhari, it is for the authentic, as for the good, it is…
- If only two students narrate from a Shaykh, both of whom are suitable for corroboration…
- The Unknown and the Accepted According to al-Hafiz: Are They One Description? A Comparison…
- Is there a case for combining the narration of an individual with that of a group, as…
- What is the ruling on a student who is a constant companion and frequent narrator from his…
- Is the scholars' statement that the narrator is more knowledgeable about his narration…
- Is there a difference between a narrator unknown by identity and a narrator unknown by…
- Why did you publish the takhrij of a hadith containing 'Umar ibn 'Ali al-Maqdami, who is…
- What is the ruling on some of the scholars of al-jarh wa al-ta'dil (the critique and…
- Can you establish a rule that every *mudallis* who frequently narrates from his shaykhs…
- What is the ruling on a student who is a constant companion and narrates frequently from…
- What is meant by the unknown identity (jahl al-'ayn)? Is it doubt about his existence in…
- On the statement of a Successor that such-and-such is from the Sunnah: why do we say it is…
- What is the difference between these phrases ("he steals hadith," "liar," "fabricator")?
- Is al-Sakhawi's statement in *Fath al-Mughith* and Ibn 'Adi's statement in *al-Kamil fi…
- A question regarding the issue of a conflict between speech and action.
- What is the position regarding a trustworthy narrator narrating alone from al-Zuhri?
- What is the ruling on Muhammad ibn Hamid al-Razi?
- Is the hadith of the thief judged as fabricated or weak? And if it is the latter, is it…
- Is there a difference between "this hadith is invalid" and "this hadith is fabricated"?
- What is the meaning of al-Haythami’s phrase in his commentary on a hadith containing…
- Is the statement of some scholars regarding a narrator whose errors are numerous, that his…
- Is the sole authentication by al-Tabarani acceptable? And is the same true for al-'Uqayli…
- What is the ruling if the opinion of a single imam differs regarding a narrator in terms…
- What is preferable when reading numbers: starting with the right or the left?
- Please clarify what is stated in *al-Silsilah al-Sahihah* regarding the weakening of the…
- A continuation regarding the disagreement of a single imam in his assessment of a…
- Is it permissible to cite the Qur'an as evidence for a weak hadith, and is its wording…
- Terminology: The difference between the expression of caution and the expression of…
- Does the rule of addition, anomaly, and acceptance apply in all contexts, or is it…
- If one of the imams narrates a hadith using the formula of weakening, is he considered…
- The Danger of Neglecting the Well-Known Rules by Individuals, Even if They Are Scholars…
- What are the limits of fame in terms of the number of people who cite it, whether many or…
- Ibn Hajar’s clarification and his approval of al-Bukhari’s practice regarding the…
- You mentioned in *Silsilat al-Da'if* (3/263), when discussing a hadith whose chain is in…
- What is the clear difference between saying so-and-so has *idrak* (awareness of the…
- If the date of the death of the narrator, the student, is before the year in which his…
- What is the importance of indications and corroborating evidence in judging hadiths?
- The questioner : Our Shaykh, regarding the obscurity of the narrator's identity (jahl…
- What is the ruling on the narrators in the *Mustakhraj* who are between the compilers of…
- If the words of al-Hafiz differ in al-Jarh wa al-Ta'dil or in establishing authenticity…
- What is the ruling on a narrator who has no biographical entry, but whose narrations were…
- What is meant by the statement of Imam al-Dhahabi, “Two scholars do not agree to…
- Why did the scholars single out shadhdh (anomaly) in the definition of a valid hadith…
- What is the validity of the statement by some students of knowledge that this man is…
- What is your opinion regarding the statement of some scholars that a sound mursal (a…
- Can it not be said that this falls under the Arabs' saying, "Two do not differ on it, and…
- What is the validity of the statement by some that the *'an'anah* of Habib ibn Abi Thabit…
- Does the issue of requiring the same gathering have any value according to the scholars?
- What is your preferred position regarding the suspended narrations in al-Bukhari that are…
- Is your statement regarding the Companion's interpretation (that it has the ruling of…
- If a scholar refers in one of his books to what he detailed in another, does that indicate…
- Does al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar have a condition regarding the hadiths he cites in al-Talkhis…
- Is the statement of al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar (We do not know of a hadith described as mutawatir…
- Is it a condition in the statement of a Companion (may Allah be pleased with him), “We…
- What is your preferred view, based on practice, regarding al-Tirmidhi’s combining of hasan…
- What is the stronger position in your view regarding the dividing line between the early…
- Al-Sakhawi criticized Ibn al-Salah for his statement that the absence of a defect is the…
- Is the concealment of equalization limited to dropping a weak narrator, or is it broader?
- What is the basis for Imam Ahmad, al-Bardiiji, and others declaring a report anomalous…
- Have you come across the words of some of the scholars of knowledge regarding the one who…
- Does Ibn Hbban's statement in *Al-Thiqat* that "the people of his town narrated from him"…
- What is the basis of al-Hakim’s definition of shadhdh in the book *Ma’rifat ‘Ulum…
- What is your opinion regarding al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar’s restriction of accepting the mursal…
- Completion of the discussion regarding Malik's action, then he added: just as it is not…
- An example of a previous question is that Ibn Hajar quotes from al-Dhahabi's Takhrij in…
- Is the Hafiz's statement about Ibn Sa'd in his book *al-Tabaqat* that he took his material…
- Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said, “If a report from the narration of a…
- And peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah, and I bear witness that there is…
- Is the number of scholars who graded a narrator as trustworthy one of the criteria for…